The contented shall inherit the Earth: The glum? Not so much
New findings offer scientific support to the ancient philosophical insights from China, Greece and India, which encourage cultivating long-term contentment or life satisfaction rather than grasping at the fleeting joy of instant gratification. Credit: © Max Sat / Flickr
The survival of the fittest might just be the survival of the steadfast instead. Having a positive attitude could be evolutionarily advantageous, according to Cornell researchers who simulated generations of evolution in a computational model.
The findings offer scientific support to the ancient philosophical insights from China, Greece and India, which encourage cultivating long-term contentment or life satisfaction rather than grasping at the fleeting joy of instant gratification, the researchers said.
“In an evolutionary sense, you have to evaluate your life on the basis of more than what happened just now,” said Shimon Edelman, professor of psychology and a co-author of the study.
The “agents” or simulated actors that survived to produce offspring in the researchers’ model were the ones that attached more weight to longer-term happiness than to momentary happiness, especially when food was scarce. They also “remembered” past happiness for a longer period of time than their less-successful counterparts. No matter whether food was abundant or scarce, the agents that had a more positive outlook — attaching more importance to upswings in their situations than to downswings — also were more evolutionarily fit. Their counterparts that gave more attention to short-term joy and a negative attitude died off.
And when agents compared their food resources with their friends’, they did worse when food was abundant.
“It may indeed be advisable, at least under conditions of scarcity or adversity, to focus on longer-term well-being or contentment over momentary pleasures and to be less envious of one’s neighbors. Also, in general, it may be wise to mark happy events more than unhappy ones,” Edelman said.
The study is based on an integrative computational framework for understanding the brain/mind, in which minds are seen as bundles of computational processes implemented by embodied and physically and socially situated brains. The computational framework enables researchers to test explicit functional models of emotions.
“Our hypothesis was, giving more weight to longer-terms considerations like life satisfaction, or at least a longer period than just right now, would be advantageous, at least in some conditions,” Edelman said.
The researchers wrote an algorithm in which agents with combinations of traits foraged for food in four types of simulated terrain over the course of six experiments. The traits included positive or negative outlooks, an emphasis on either short-term (hedonic) or long-term (eudaimonic) happiness, and a tendency or an aversion to comparing performance to that of friends. Each type of terrain had a different distribution of food, from a random and scarce pattern to a more clustered and abundant distribution.
Each environment was populated with 400 agents in each generation for 40 generations and repeated each of the six experiments 10 times.
After a set number of cycles, each agent in the top half of performers was allowed to produce offspring that formed the next generation of agents. The bottom 50 percent was terminated. In this way, the researchers assessed the effectiveness of traits by tracking their prevalence in the population over evolutionary time.
The researchers also found the only situation in which those with a more conservative outlook had a higher level of evolutionary fitness was a harsh environment, in which poison was distributed along with food.
What does the study say for those who seek a clear path to happiness?
Know thyself, Edelman said.
“Instead of relying blindly on advice from self-help authors about how to be happy, get to know yourself — what your brain/mind is like, how it works and how it interacts with the world — and you’ll be in a better position to decide for yourself,” Edelman said.
Popular on Science Bulletin
- Wisdom is a matter of both heart and mind, research finds
- Money really does matter in relationships
- When you take acetaminophen, you don’t feel others’ pain as much
- Before animals, evolution waited eons to inhale
- How did birds get their wings? Bacteria may provide a clue, say scientists
- You are not as anonymous as you think online
- Lucy had neighbors: A review of African fossils
- Social responsibility promotes conservative risk behavior
- Inbred Neanderthals left humans a genetic burden
- Evolutionary biologists show that sexual selection increases the number of species and impacts global diversity
- Migration back to Africa took place during the Palaeolithic
- Some bacteria have lived in the human gut since before we were human
- New study shows how age, sex affect social activity
- Real men don’t say ‘cute': Psychologists tap big data and Twitter to analyze the accuracy of stereotypes